Why B-flat Harmonic Major is Preferred
The A-sharp harmonic major scale requires ten sharps in its key signature and involves double-sharp notation (particularly for the raised seventh degree), making it exceptionally difficult to read and write. In contrast, B-flat harmonic major uses only two flats and requires no accidentals beyond natural notation, offering identical pitches with vastly superior readability. This dramatic difference in notational complexity means that A-sharp harmonic major appears virtually nowhere in published music, pedagogical materials, or performance practice.
Practice Recommendations
If you encounter or wish to practice this pitch collection, always use B-flat harmonic major instead. Learning to read and perform in B-flat harmonic major provides all the same musical benefits without the burden of navigating multiple double sharps. For theoretical understanding of enharmonic relationships, recognize that A-sharp and B-flat harmonic major are acoustically identical on modern equal-tempered instruments, but B-flat notation is the universally accepted standard for this scale.